Mortgage
Loans - secret methods that drive up the cost of your home purchase
or refinance.
There
are an enormous amount of fees associated with doing a loan. Most
of them are fees that the loan officer and mortgage company cannot
control, and are a part of every loan. In the case of the rest of
the loan fees, the loan officer is in complete control of how much
they will make off of a loan. Unfortunately, the typical consumer
is unaware of these costs because they are hidden (legally so) in
the loan paperwork and closing documents. However, laws are in the
process of being drafted to correct this outright thievery.
In order
to understand how a mortgage company makes money on a loan, you
first need to understand which of these costs are profitable for
the mortgage company. You can read our article on the real costs
of doing a loan.
Fees
Which Profit the Mortgage Company
The following fees determine the profit on the loan. They are completely
under the control of the loan officer or mortgage broker. There
is no standard for these fees; the unscrupulous loan officer will
try and make as much as possible from you with these fees. After
being in the loan business, I watched loan officers gouging their
clients every day. It is a rampant, common occurrence. Most loan
officers are not paid a salary, they are paid through commissions
from every loan they originate that closes. This puts the pressure
on them to make as much money as possible, wherever possible. Loan
officers typically split the profits (usually 50/50) for each loan
with the company for which they work. Therefore, every dollar they
can squeeze out of you is 50 cents into their pocket. To originate
a loan, the loan officer merely gets a client to fill out a loan
application.
Origination
or Application Fees: These are fees for processing the mortgage
application and may be a flat fee or a percentage of the mortgage.
They usually are equal to one point. In fact, they are just a point
called by a fancy name so the loan officer can charge more for the
loan.
Points:
A point is equal to 1% of the amount borrowed. For example, one
point on a loan amount of $50,000.00 is $500.00 dollars. Points
can be payable when the loan is approved (before closing) or at
closing. For FHA and VA mortgages, the seller-not the buyer-must
pay the points. Even if you are not using an FHA or VA mortgage,
you may want to negotiate points in the purchase offer. Some lenders
will let you finance points, adding this cost to the mortgage, which
will increase your interest costs. If you pay the points up front,
they are deductible from your income taxes in the year they are
paid. Different deductibility rules apply to second homes.
Application
Fees: Application fees are non-refundable and 100% pure profit
for the mortgage broker. Walk out if they ask for an application
fee up front. The only exception to this rule is if you have tough
credit. In this case, the loan officer will have to do a lot of
work before he can tell if your loan will go through. Time is money
and he will want to be paid for this effort. If your loan gets denied
without an application fee up front, the loan officer has put in
a lot of hours for nothing.
Points
"On the Back": These are fees and commissions earned
by the mortgage broker by selling you a loan whose interest rate
is above the going rate. More about this later in this chapter.
The "normal fees" in the industry are an origination fee
(1 "point") plus one additional point. Some brokers have
a limit on how much a loan officer can charge in fees-the loan application
fee, the origination fee, and the points, but not all. However,
there is no absolute hard and fast rules.
Getting
Points on the Back
Also known as "yield-spread fees", points on the back
are one of the ways a loan officer makes more funds available to
the total loan "kitty." It is essentially a "kick-back"
from the mortgage bank the loan officer is buying the loan from,
earned by selling a customer a loan at an interest rate that is
above the going rate.
Each
day, loan officers receive rates from banks for all of their loan
programs. Listed for each program is the "par interest rate."
The par interest rate is the interest rate at which the broker does
not have to pay a fee to "buy" the loan and then sell
it to you, nor does he receive a commission for selling you the
loan at this rate. You might say that the par rate is "loan
equilibrium." Table 3 shows an example of the types of rates
a bank might publish to their subscribing mortgage companies every
day.
EXAMPLE
RATE SHEET ON A 30-YEAR LOAN
6.5 6.75 7.0 7.25 7.5
15-day Lock .50 .25 0.00 (.5) (1.5)
30-day Lock .75 .50 .25 0.00 (.25)
45-day Lock 1.50 .75 .50 .25 0.00
60-day Lock 2.50 1.00 .75 .50 .25
In the
above example, the "par" value for a 15-day lock is 7.0%.
The numbers in parentheses are the points returned to the loan proceeds
as additional funds to offset the costs of the loan (or as a commission
for loan officer). Why would anyone knowingly pay this higher rate?
To get a "no-cost loan," which I will talk about next.
For example,
if you wanted a $150,000.00 loan, but didn't have enough to cover
the loan costs, you could bump up your interest rate to 7.5%, giving
you: $150,000.00 x 1.5%/100 = $2,250.00.
This
money will be credited to the loan proceeds at closing. What does
this mean? It means that if your closing costs are $2,250.00, you
won't have to lay out a dime to do the loan. Keep in mind, though,
that if you are purchasing a home, you can't just up the interest
rate to get your down payment. You must have enough money for the
down payment.
And if
you didn't know that the rate you were getting was higher than the
par rate (meaning you paid full loan costs)? The loan officer gets
that $2,250.00. Do some loan officers "forget" to tell
you about this little loan surplus? Unfortunately, yes; it is one
of the most profitable methods used by loan officers.
No-cost
Loans
You've heard of those no-cost refinance loans? Forget it. There
is no such thing. A broker must make money on every loan. Many well-intentioned
loan officers honestly believe they are giving you a loan for free,
but this simply is not the case.
In the
example above, I showed you how you could get a loan at an interest
rate above the par rate and get points on the back. The points on
the back translate to extra funds available to pay the cost of the
loan plus pay the loan officer a commission. So what's wrong with
this? Nothing, but you are financing the "free cost" of
the loan over the term of the loan (usually 30 years), which can
double or triple the closing costs (by way of additional interest)
as compared to pay the closing costs in cash.
How
Do You Know if the Loan Officer is Jacking up Your Interest Rate?
It bears repeating that it is the loan officer who picks the interest
rate he is going to sell you and, consequently, the commissions
he will earn on the loan. If he is competing with another loan company
to get your loan, he may not be greedy and not jack up the rate.
But if you don't shop around, don't trust him to be honest. Some
loan officers are completely up-front with you, but some aren't.
Always shop around, especially if you have "A" credit.
Some loan officers will charge you less if they know your loan will
be a piece of cake to put through the system.
Take
extra caution if you have less than stellar credit and must get
a non-conforming loan, as these are typically the biggest target
of shady loan officers. Desperate people have been known to have
swallowed higher interest rates and 5 points in fees. This definitely
is gouging.
The
coming legislation?
The Washington Post stated in an article titled Mortgage Brokers
Likely to Disclose Fees Under New U.S. Guidelines that "An
estimated 150 class-action suits are now pending in federal courts
around the country pitting groups of borrowers against lenders who
paid yield-spread fees to brokers". If plaintiffs, numbering
30,000 in one lawsuit alone, are victorious, the the potential settlement
cost is quoted by the Post to be $135 million. Naturally, as such
costs could put a good percentage lenders out of business, many
are asking for better clarification by Housing and Urban Development
(HUD) as protection.
HUD is in the process of recommending new legislation governing
the home-buying process. In a press release issued on October 15,
2001, HUD's Housing Secretary Mel Martinez stated some of the key
goals of the new legislation:
Full,
upfront disclosure of all costs associated with obtaining a home
loan in understandable terms prior to the payment of non-refundable
fees. Full disclosure would be a description of the specific services
to be performed by the broker, a statement of whether the broker
is acting as an agent for the borrower, and the amount of the total
compensation to the broker, including any yield spread premium paid
by a lender. In addition, HUD believes that the broker should explain
the various loan options. The borrower should be informed that he
or she may pay higher upfront costs for a mortgage with a lower
interest rate, or conversely pay a higher interest rate in return
for lower upfront costs. In the latter case, the broker may be receiving
a yield spread premium.
Clarification
of Yield Spread Premiums - payments made by lenders for loans
with higher interest rates. HUD's statement of policy says that
yield spread premiums are legal if the broker actually performs
services for the homebuyer, and if the total compensation the broker
receives is reasonably related to the total value of the services
the broker performs. Disclosure is especially important when borrowers
may be paying yield spread premiums. Borrowers should know as early
as possible what their settlement costs will be, so that they can
shop for the best option.
Clarification
of current HUD policy that states that consumer payments are not
legal if they are overcharges, or if no service is provided. HUD
is restating and clarifying its policy that excessive and unreasonable
fees are illegal under RESPA because they are unreasonable and not
a payment for a bona fide service.
The new
policy will make clear that it is illegal for a settlement service
provider to mark-up fees when it is making a payment to another
settlement service provider, unless it provides additional value
to the homebuyer in the process, or when a provider does no work
for the fee and charges an unreasonable amount.
Expansion
of RESPA enforcement. Last year, HUD fielded more than 900 RESPA-related
complaints, approximately one-third involving kickbacks and other
questionable payments.
Currently,
these measure are not enforceable by law, and are just guidelines.
You can do your part and lobby your local government representative.
|