Understanding
Credit Insurance
Credit insurance is insurance that guarantees or secures payment
of an outstanding obligation in a credit transaction in the event
that the borrower is unable to pay. For instance, a consumer purchases
a car. The dealer arranges for the consumer to obtain a loan for
the purchase, perhaps seller financing. During the transaction,
the dealer encourages the consumer to purchase credit insurance
as security, in case something should happen rendering the consumer
unable to make the required payments on the loan. Not wanting to
risk losing the family car should he or she become disabled or die,
the consumer agrees to purchase credit insurance. The same pattern
is often repeated in other credit transactions as well, including
sales of consumer goods, mobile home sales, and residential mortgages.
Creditors
have an incentive to sell credit insurance for several reasons.
There is incentive not only because the creditor is the primary
beneficiary under a credit insurance policy, but also because the
creditor receives significant compensation from the sale of insurance
from the insurer whose product it sells, and because interest is
charged when the creditor finances the insurance premium.
Older
Americans may be more susceptible than other consumers to credit
insurance sales pitches. This is because they are more aware of
their own mortality or risk of becoming disabled than younger people,
and may perceive their overall risk of loss of income more keenly.
Creditors are not unaware of this state of mind and in some circumstances
might try to take advantage it.
Types of Credit Insurance
There
are four basic types of credit insurance. They are credit property,
credit life, credit disability (a.k.a. accident and health insurance),
and involuntary loss of income insurance. Except for credit property
insurance, which protects against loss of the collateral through
some casualty, all other forms of credit insurance protect against
some casualty befalling the borrower. As with other kinds of insurance,
the borrower ordinarily will have to meet eligibility requirements
under the particular policy in order for the insurance to have effect.
Credit
Property Insurance
Insures
against damage or loss to the collateral securing the loan. This
type of insurance is commonly required in credit transactions such
as home mortgages or car purchases. This is because a creditor has
little recourse for recovering its investment once the collateral
is damaged or destroyed and the benefit of foreclosure or repossession
is lost along with the collateral itself. Even if property insurance
is required, however, under most states' insurance laws the creditor
cannot require the borrower to purchase it through the creditor.
Credit
Life Insurance
Insures
that if the consumer dies, the outstanding loan balance will be
paid. Eligibility for credit life usually includes limitations on
pre-existing health conditions. The policy will often state that
coverage is not provided for losses due to conditions commencing
or treated prior to application for insurance or within a specified
period of time following the effective date of the policy. Other
policies state that there is no coverage unless the applicant is
in "sound" or good" health when the insurance becomes
effective. In addition, most policies state that an applicant beyond
a certain age cannot obtain coverage, or that coverage expires when
an insured person reaches that age.
Credit
Disability/Accident and Health Insurance
Insures
the consumer against varying disabilities resulting from accident
or ill health (other than pre-existing conditions). These policies
only cover the periodic payments that come due during a disability,
and usually require that the consumer be incapacitated for a minimum
period of time before any payments begin. The consumer usually must
be a full-time worker to be eligible for benefits. The sooner payments
begin, the more expensive the premiums will be.
Involuntary
loss of income insurance
Insures
against layoff or other causes of involuntary loss of income, as
the policy may specify. Like disability coverage, policies for involuntary
loss of income typically state that coverage does not become effective
unless the applicant is, for example, actively at work," "regularly
performing the duties of his/her occupation," or "gainfully
employed" on the policy's effective date. In addition, no coverage
is ordinarily provided when the loss of income results from the
consumer's voluntary actions (e.g., resignation).
Common
Credit Insurance Abuses
There
are four common credit insurance abuses. They include involuntary
or pressured sales techniques, price overcharges in sales to eligible
borrowers, sale of incomplete coverage, and post-claim ineligibility
determination by the insurance company.
Involuntary
or Pressured Sales Techniques
Creditors
may not require credit insurance, except for property insurance
in some circumstances, as a condition of the loan. Where credit
insurance is an option, consumers may be misled by creditors into
thinking that it is required. When it is required, in only a very
few cases can lenders explicitly require borrowers to purchase insurance
from the lender; state law usually prohibits such a requirement,
and the federal Truth in Lending Act (15 U.S.C. §1601 et seq.)
also imposes certain restrictions on this practice.
Price
Overcharges
There
are at least three ways in which a creditor can overcharge for credit
insurance. One is to charge a premium rate higher than that permitted
by premium finance law or regulation. Another is to recommend the
purchase of insurance coverage in excess of that allowable under
law or necessary to protect the loan. Finally, a level life policy
may be sold where a decreasing life policy is called for.
Sale of Incomplete Coverage
As consumer loan amounts grow larger and terms grow longer (especially
in mortgage transactions), the cost of long-term credit insurance
can be prohibitive. Therefore, it is becoming more common for creditors
to sell credit insurance which does not completely insure the loan.
For example, a 10-year, $10,000 policy may be sold in connection
with a 15-year, $15,000 loan, but the policy may be misrepresented
to the consumer as covering the full term and amount of the loan.
Thus, when an event occurs requiring payoff of the loan under the
policy, the consumer (or her survivors) may be left obligated personally
for an outstanding balance.
Post-Claim
Ineligibility Determination
This scenario usually arises because of some conduct or omission
by the creditor who sold the insurance, even though he knew or have
known that the borrower was ineligible (ineligibility factors may
include the consumer's age or health or employment status, depending
on the type of coverage purchased and the specific policy requirements).
Common situations include:
- the creditor has knowledge of a policy condition that would disqualify
the consumer, but does not share the information with the insurer;
- the
creditor fails to make any inquiry about the consumer's age, health
or other relevant facts;
-the
creditor deliberately misstates information on the insurance application;
-the
creditor fails to process the application properly.
Is
Credit Insurance Necessary
Generally
speaking, insurance is nice to have. However, it is not a necessity.
Whether or not to purchase credit insurance ultimately is a matter
of personal choice and one's assessment of individual risk versus
the cost of premiums. If having credit insurance is your personal
choice, you could probably minimize the cost by shopping for alternative
types of insurance which would serve the purpose.
Credit
insurance offered through the lender is usually not a good bargain
for the money, given the narrow benefits. A better deal for the
money is likely to be adequate insurance of a more general type.
For example, disability insurance not tied to the debt offers the
possibility of replacing income, as well. The difference is the
insured can direct the monthly benefits to wherever he or she thinks
is most important. For example, the consumer may prefer to use it
to make the mortgage payment, even if it means defaulting on a car
loan. Similarly, a general life insurance policy in an amount adequate
to meet the borrower's needs gives the insured the freedom to set
priorities for debt repayment.Older consumers may sometimes feel
that credit insurance is desirable because underwriting requirements
make it difficult for them to obtain these other types of insurance.
If that
is the case, credit insurance is worth exploring, but do it wisely:
- Ask
what limitations and exclusions there are on paying the benefits.
Tell them you want the answer in writing. If they won't do that,
be wary.
-Ask
for a clear explanation of the benefits.
-Check
carefully the premium price -- which can run into thousands of dollars.
Ask the creditor to give you a comparison of your monthly payment
amount and the total debt, both with and without the insurance.
If the price of the insurance makes the monthly payments uncomfortably
high given your income, it may make default more likely. If it is
an unsecured loan for a car, you may decide to take that risk. If
it is a mortgage on your home, you may weigh the risk of death or
disability differently against the relative risk of default.
If you
already have credit insurance in connection with a prior transaction
and feel like you were misled or abused in a manner described above,
contact an attorney immediately.
|